Nostalgia
Showing 49–72 of 91 results
-
French Burnt Peanuts 10oz Bag
$4.99 -
Frooties 8oz Bag
$3.99 -
Fruit Slices 12oz Container
$5.99 -
Giant Jawbreakers 1 Jawbreaker, 2.5in
$2.99 -
Jolly Ranchers 8 ounce Bag
$4.99 -
Jordan Almonds 8 oz bag
$5.99 -
Laffy Taffy 8oz Bag
$3.99 -
Lemon Heads 12oz Bag
$4.99 -
Marshmallow Cones 24 Count
$19.99 -
Marzipan 9 Piece
$7.99 -
Mega Sour Warheads
$2.99 -
Molasses Puffs 5oz Bag
$5.99 -
Necco Wafers – 2oz roll
$1.49 -
Nerd Rope 10in Long
$1.49 -
Now and Later – 8oz Bag
$3.99 -
Peanut Brittle
$6.99 -
Peanut Butter Cups
$29.99 -
Peanut Butter Smoothie
$33.00 -
Pecan Log 3oz Package
$2.99 -
Pop Rocks Strawberry 0.33oz Package
$0.99 -
Pop Rocks Tropical Punch 0.33oz Package
$0.99 -
Pop Rocks Watermelon 0.33 ounce Package
$0.99 -
Razzles Original 1.4oz Package
$1.99 -
Razzles Sour 1.4oz Package
$1.99