Nostalgia

Showing all 99 results

• 

  5TH AVENUE CANDY BAR

  5TH AVENUE CANDY BAR CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER IN A RICH, CHOCOLATE COATING

  $1.29
• 

  Abba Zabba

  First copyrighted in 1922, Abba Zabba is a chewy taffy with a peanut butter center. It was the favorite candy bar of actor John Wayne.

  $1.99
• 

  After Dinner Mints

  12 Ounces

  $4.99
• 

  Anise Squares

  12 Ounces

  $3.99
• 

  Assorted Swedish Fish

  10 Ounce Bag

  $3.99
• 

  Atomic Fireballs 12 Ounce Bag

  Great Balls of Fire!!!12 ounce bag

  $3.99
• 

  BANANA CANDIES – 12 ounce bag

  LIKE ASSORTED RUNTS, BUT JUST THE BEST FLAVOR

  $3.99
• 

  Banana Splits 12 ounce Bag

  Old fashioned banana flavored taffy12 oz

  $3.99
• 

  Beemans Chewing Gum – 20 packs

  Twenty packs of gum with five sticks in each pack.

  $13.00
• 

  Bit-O-Honey 12 ounce Bag

  Bite size molasses taffy with a tase of honey.12 oz

  $3.99
• 

  Black Jack Chewing Gum – 20 packs

  Twenty packs of licorice flavored gum with five sticks in each pack.

  $13.00
• 

  Blo Pops 8 ounce Bag

  Charms pops filled with bubble gum.Assorted flavors 10 oz

  $3.99
• 

  Boston Baked Beans 12 ounce Bag

  Fill your beanpot with the original Boston beans(candy coated peanuts)14 oz

  $4.99
• 

  Bottle Caps Box 5 ounce

  Cola, Cherry, Grape, Root Beer, Orange5 Oz

  $1.99
• 

  Bubble Gum Cigarettes 8 Per Box

  Blow smoke out with these.8 smokes per pack

  $1.49
• 

  Bubble Gum Cigars

  8 Count

  $3.99
• 

  Butterfinger 2.5 ounce Bar

  Butterfinger 2.5 ounce Bar

  $1.29
• 

  Canada Mints Pink 10 ounce Bag

  Wintergreen 10 oz

  $3.99
• 

  Candy Blox

  8 Ounces

  $3.99
• 

  Candy Cigarettes-24 boxes

  Politcally correct they’re called “Candy Stix”Minty white sticks with the red tip. 24 boxes each with 10 cigarettes

  $8.99
• 

  Caramel Apple Pops – 48 Count Box

  $10.99
• 

  Caramellos 5 count

  A rare treat! Marshmallow covered in soft caramel. Difficult to make, expensive, but oh sooooo good. 5 INDIVUAL PIECES

  $16.99
• 

  Charleston Chew Chocolate

  Try Frozen 8 inches long

  $1.29
• 

  Charleston Chew Strawberry

  Try frozen 8 inches long

  $1.29
• 

  Charleston Chew Vanilla

  Try Frozen.  8 inches long

  $1.29
• 

  Charms Lollipops – 48 Count Box

  $14.99
• 

  Charms Lollipops – Sweet & Sour – 48 Count Box

  $14.99
• 

  CHICK-O-STICK

  Each

  $1.49
• 

  Chocolate Gummi Bears 8 ounces

  Imported gummi bears covered with a special milk chocolate.

  $5.99
• 

  Chocolate Necco Wafers – 2 ounce roll

  $1.49
• 

  Chocolate Necco Wafers – 24 Rolls

  24 –  2 ounce rolls

  $29.99
• 

  Chuckles 2 ounce Package

  Even the name says FUN!!!5 count

  $1.29
• 

  Chunky Bar 1.4 ounce Bar

  $1.49
• 

  Cinnamon Bears 10 ounce Container

  Hot cinnamon flavored juji bears10 Oz

  $3.99
• 

  Cinnamon Hots 12 .9oz boxes

  Red Hots! Pop a handful in your mouth, or add some kick to your homemade applesauce.12  .9 oz boxes

  $3.99
• 

  Circus Peanuts – 8 ounce bag

  $3.99
• 

  Clove Chewing Gum – 20 packs

  Twenty packs of gum with five sticks in each pack.

  $13.00
• 

  Coconut Bon Bons 16 ounces

  Coconut with chocolate, strawberry, vanilla or lemon candy shell.1 pound tray

  $4.99
• 

  Coconut Haystacks 10 ounce Bag

  Coconut Haystacks 10 ounce Bag

  $5.99
• 

  CROWS

  Theatre size box of black licorice buttons8.5 oz

  $1.99
• 

  Cry Baby Teardrops 12 ounce Bag

  Sour candies that will make you cry.12 oz

  $3.99
• 

  DIVINITY 8 OZ CONTAINER

  8 OZ OF DIVINITY WHIPPED NOUGAT WITH CHOPPED PECAN

  $4.99
• 

  Dubble Bubble Gum 8 ounce Bag

  Dubble Bubble Gum 8 ounce Bag

  $2.99
• 

  DUM DUM POPS

  8 ouncesaprox 30 pops

  $3.99
• 

  Flying Saucers Box Of 240

  Super-light wafers filled with candy beads.Did you “Play Church” with these? 240 saucers

  $26.00
• 

  Frooties 8 ounce Bag

  ‘- Chewy Tootsie candies with intense flavors like Blue Raspberry, Grape, Green Apple, Lime Cola, Fruit Punch and more8 Oz assorted

  $3.99
• 

  Fruit Slices 12 ounce Container

  An assortment of rasbpberry, lemon, lime & orange fruit slices.12 oz tray

  $5.99
• 

  Fruit Stripe Gum – 17 Stick Package

  5 Juicy Flavors with 17 sticks

  $1.29
• 

  Giant Gumballs 12 Ounces

  1 Inch Gumballs – assorted colors12 Ounce Bag

  $3.99
• 

  Giant Jawbreakers 1 Jawbreaker, 2.5 Inches

  Huge.2.5 inches

  $1.99
• 

  Ginger Drops 12 ounce Bag

  Ginger Drops 14 ounce Bag

  $3.99
• 

  Gobstopper Family Size 5 ounce Box

  The jawbreaker that changes color in your mouth.

  $1.99
• 

  Hot Tamales – 12 ounce Bag

  Hot Tamales 12 ounce Bag

  $3.99
• 

  Jawbreakers 12 ounce

  Assorted colors12 oz

  $3.99
• 

  Jolly Ranchers 12 ounce Bag

  Bite SizeAssorted flavors:Apple, Blue Raspberry, Cherry, Grape, Watermelon12 Oz

  $3.99
• 

  Laffy Taffy 8 ounce Bag

  ‘- Two jokes on each wrapper.Strawberry, grape, banana & sour apple. 8 oz

  $3.99
• 

  Lemon Heads 12 ounce Bag

  Lemon Heads 14 ounce Bag

  $3.99
• 

  Mallow Cups 1.6 ounce

  Boyer’s famous chocolate cups filled with marshmallow creme.box of 24

  $28.00
• 

  Mary Janes 3 ounce Bag

  Old fashioned peanut butter taffy square.3 oz

  $2.99
• 

  Marzipan 9 Piece

  An almond paste delicacy.4 oz

  $6.99
• 

  Mega Sour Warheads

  20 ct

  $2.99
• 

  Molasses Puffs 5 ounce Bag

  Also called Sponge, Seafoam or Ferry Food.5 oz

  $4.99
• 

  Necco Wafers – 2 ounce roll

  Roll of assorted flavors – 2 ounces

  $1.49
• 

  Necco Wafers – 24 Rolls

  Box of 24 Rolls of assorted flavors – 2 ounces each

  $29.99
• 

  NERD FILLED GUM – 8 ounce bag

  $3.99
• 

  Nerd Rope 10 Inches Long

  Long gummi stick with Nerd candy beads stuck to it.10 inches long

  $1.49
• 

  Now and Later – 8 ounce bag

  $3.99
• 

  Peanut Brittle

  12 Ounces

  $6.99
• 

  Peanut Butter Cups

  One Pound

  $24.99
• 

  PEANUT BUTTER SMOOTHIE

  ‘- Boyer’s famous butterscotch filled peanut butter cup.box of 24

  $28.00
• 

  Pecan Log 3 ounce Package

  Pecans wrapped around a rich caramel & nougat filling.

  $1.99
• 

  Pixie Stix 3.5 ounce Bag

  Paper straws filled with pixie dust(flavored sugar).40 per bag

  $3.99
• 

  Pop Rocks Strawberry 0.33 ounce Package

  $0.99
• 

  Pop Rocks Tropical Punch 0.33 ounce Package

  $0.99
• 

  Pop Rocks Watermelon 0.33 ounce Package

  $0.99
• 

  Razzles Original 1.4 ounce Package

  First it’s candy, then it’s gum.

  $1.49
• 

  Razzles Sour 1.4 ounce Package

  Sour flavorsFirst it’s candy, then it’s gum.

  $1.49
• 

  Reed’s Rolls

  Select Root Beer, Butterscotch or Cinnamon

  $0.99
• 

  Reeses Pieces 8 ounce Bag

  E.T.’s favorite peanut butter filled candy shells.10 oz

  $3.99
• 

  Rock Candy 10 ounce Bag

  Crystalized sugar on string.10 oz

  $4.99
• 

  Rock Candy Stix

  Assorted colors and flavors on swizzle stick.6 stix

  $4.99
• 

  ROLO

  Chewy Caramels in milk chocolate1.7 ounces

  $1.29
• 

  Rootbeer Barrels 14 ounce Bag

  Rootbeer Barrels 14 ounce Bag

  $3.99
• 

  Scented Gum Box 8 Piece Box

  20 Packs

  $24.00
• 

  Sky Bars Box Of 24

  4 fillings in each bar.Vanilla, caramel, peanut butter & fudge.box of 24

  $59.99
• 

  Smarties Wrapped 10 ounce Bag

  Smarties Wrapped 10 ounce Bag

  $3.99
• 

  Sour Power Straws 6 ounce Bag

  Watermelon, strawberry & tropical punch chewy sour straws you can actually drink through.6 oz

  $3.99
• 

  Sugar Babies 1.7 ounce pouch

  Chewy, soft to chew, milk caramel sweets

  $1.29
• 

  Sugar Daddies 8 ounce Bag

  Caramel lollipops that last a long time.8 oz(about 15 pops)

  $3.99
• 

  Tart N Tiny – 1.5 ounce

  $1.99
• 

  Tootsie Pop Drops 2.25 ounce Package

  Tootsie Pops without the stick! 2.25 Oz package

  $1.49
• 

  Tootsie Rolls 14 ounce Bag

  Tootsie Rolls 14 ounce Bag

  $3.99
• 

  Tootsie Rolls Flavored 14 ounce Bag

  Like the original Tootsie Roll, but in vanilla, cherry, orange, lemon & lime.14 oz

  $3.99
• 

  Violet Squares 15 Mint Package

  C.Howard’s The candy with the unmistakable violet flavor.15 mints per pack

  $1.29
• 

  WAX FANGS

  Each

  $1.49
• 

  Wax Lips

  each

  $1.49
• 

  Wax Mustache

  EACH

  $1.49
• 

  Zagnut Bar

  1.51 Ounces

  $1.49
• 

  Zero Bar 1.85 ounce

  EACH

  $1.29