Nostalgia
Showing all 124 results
-
Abba Zabba
First copyrighted in 1922, Abba Zabba is a chewy taffy with a peanut butter center. It was the favorite candy bar of actor John Wayne.
$1.99 -
After Dinner Mints
12 Ounces
$3.99 -
Anise Squares
12 Ounces
$3.99 -
Assorted Candy Sticks 12 Assorted Sticks
Assorted Candy Sticks 12 Assorted Sticks
$2.99 -
Atkinson Peanut Bar
12 Ounces
$3.99 -
Atomic Fireballs 12 Ounce Bag
Great Balls of Fire!!!12 ounce bag
$3.99 -
Baby Ruth 2.1 ounce Bar
Baby Ruth candy bars is made with caramel, peanuts, chocolate nougat, covered in a compound chocolate. The bar was first introduced in 1921 by the Curtis Candy Company. Although they were located on the same street as Wrigley Field, the company denied it was named after the famous baseball player Babe Ruth, instead claiming it…
$1.29 -
Banana Splits 12 ounce Bag
Old fashioned banana flavored taffy12 oz
$3.99 -
BB BATS
Chocolate, Strawberry, Peanut Butter & Banana24 pops
$2.99 -
Bit-O-Honey 12 ounce Bag
Bite size molasses taffy with a tase of honey.12 oz
$3.99 -
Blo Pops 8 ounce Bag
Charms pops filled with bubble gum.Assorted flavors 10 oz
$3.99 -
Bonomo Banana Taffy 1.5 ounce Bar
Back by popular demand! Crack it up!1.5 Oz bar
$1.29 -
Bonomo Chocolate Taffy 1.5 ounce Bar
Back by popular demand!Crack it Up!1.5 Oz
$1.29 -
Bonomo Strawberry Taffy 1.5ounce Bar
Back by popular demand!Crack it Up!1.5 Oz bar
$1.29 -
Bonomo Vanilla Taffy 1.5 ounce Bar
Back by popular demand!Crack it Up!1.5 Oz bar
$1.29 -
Boston Baked Beans 12 ounce Bag
Fill your beanpot with the original Boston beans(candy coated peanuts)14 oz
$3.99 -
Bottle Caps Box 5 ounce
Cola, Cherry, Grape, Root Beer, Orange5 Oz
$1.99 -
Bubble Gum Cigarettes 8 Per Box
Blow smoke out with these.8 smokes per pack
$0.99 -
Bubble Gum Cigars
8 Count
$3.99 -
Butterfinger 2.5 ounce Bar
Butterfinger 2.5 ounce Bar
$1.29 -
Canada Mints Green 14 ounce Bag
Canada Mints Spearmint14 oz
$3.99 -
Canada Mints Pink 14 ounce Bag
Wintergreen14 oz
$3.99 -
Canada Mints White 14 ounce Bag
Peppermint14 oz
$3.99 -
Candy Blox
8 Ounces
$2.99 -
Candy Buttons
4 strips of candy pills to peel off the paper. Remember when you pretended to be the doctor. From NECCO candy.
$1.99 -
Candy Cigarettes-24 boxes
Politcally correct they’re called “Candy Stix”Minty white sticks with the red tip. 24 boxes each with 10 cigarettes
$5.99 -
Candy Necklaces 5 Count
Colored candy beads strung as necklaces.5 count
$1.99 -
Caramel Cream-Strawberry 14 ounce Bag
Strawberri caramel around a creamy white center.14 oz
$3.99 -
Caramel Creme-Chocolate 14 ounce Bag
Chocolate caramel around a creamy white center.14 oz
$3.99 -
Caramel Cremes 14 ounce Bag
The original “Bullseye”Caramel around a creamy smooth white center.14 oz
$3.99 -
Caramellos
A rare treat! Marshmallow covered in soft caramel. Difficult to make, expensive, but oh sooooo good.
$2.49 -
Charleston Chew Chocolate 24 Per Box
Try Frozen8 inches long24 ct
$24.00 -
Charleston Chew Vanilla Box Of 24
Try Frozen8 inches long24 count
$24.00 -
Charlston Chew Strawberry 24 Per Box
Try frozen8 inches long24 count
$24.00 -
Cherry Sours 12 ounce Bag
Soft and chewy.14 oz
$3.99 -
Chewy Spree 12 ounce Bag
Chewy Spree 12 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
CHICK-O-STICK
Each
$0.99 -
Chocolate Gummi Bears 8 ounces
Imported gummi bears covered with a special milk chocolate.
$5.99 -
Chocolate Sponge – Dark 8 ounces
Popular Molasses puffs dipped in dark chocolate
$4.99 -
Chocolate Starlite Mints 14 ounce Bag
Chocolate Starlite Mints 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Chocolate Stars 12 ounce Bag
SWEET MILK CHOCOLATE IN A CELESTIAL SHAPE!
$3.99 -
Chuckles 2 ounce Package
Even the name says FUN!!!5 count
$1.29 -
Chunky Bar 1.4 ounce Bar
$1.29 -
Cinnamon Bears 10 ounce Container
Hot cinnamon flavored juji bears10 Oz
$3.99 -
Cinnamon Hots 12 ounce Bag
Red Hots! Pop a handful in your mouth, or add some kick to your homemade applesauce.12 oz
$3.99 -
Coconut Bon Bons 16 ounces
Coconut with chocolate, strawberry, vanilla or lemon candy shell.1 pound tray
$4.99 -
Coconut Creamsicles 8 ounce
$4.99 -
Coconut Haystacks 10 ounce Bag
Coconut Haystacks 10 ounce Bag
$5.99 -
Coconut Macaroons 8 ounce Container
Lightly toasted, moist & chewy coconut
$4.99 -
Coconut Sundaes 8 ounce Container
Bacon Strips Pressed coconut – chocolate,coconut,watermelon8 oz tray
$4.99 -
Coconut Watermelon Slices 8 ounce Container
Strips of pressed coconut with watermelon flavor.8 oz tray
$4.99 -
CREME MINT WAFERS
10 wafers per box
Choose assorted or wintergreen
$3.99 -
CROWS
Theatre size box of black licorice buttons8.5 oz
$1.99 -
Cry Baby Teardrops 12 ounce Bag
Sour candies that will make you cry.12 oz
$2.99 -
Dubble Bubble Gum 8 ounce Bag
Dubble Bubble Gum 8 ounce Bag
$2.99 -
DUM DUM POPS
8 ouncesaprox 30 pops
$2.99 -
Filled Peanuts 12 ounce Bag
Filled Peanuts 12 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Flying Saucers Box Of 240
Super-light wafers filled with candy beads.Did you “Play Church” with these? 240 saucers
$24.00 -
FORT KNOX HUGE MEDALLIONS
2 Ounces of milk chocolate4 inch diameterType in color–Gold, Silver or Bronze
$2.99 -
Fortune Bubble Gum-48 pieces
With Great Gum Comes Great FortuneBack by popular demand48 sticks with Chinese furtune inside
$4.99 -
French Burnt Peanuts 12 ounce Bag
Peanuts covered with a crispy outer shell.12 oz
$3.99 -
Frooties 8 ounce Bag
‘- Chewy Tootsie candies with intense flavors like Blue Raspberry, Grape, Green Apple, Lime Cola, Fruit Punch and more8 Oz assorted
$2.99 -
Frozen Pez Dispenser(Choose Character)
Frozen PezChoose from Anna, Elsa or Olaf
$1.99 -
Fruit Slices 12 ounce Container
An assortment of rasbpberry, lemon, lime & orange fruit slices.12 oz tray
$4.99 -
Fruit Stripe Gum Box 12-17 Stick Packages
5 Juicy Flavors12 packages with 17 sticks
$14.00 -
Giant Gumballs 12 Ounces
1 Inch Gumballs – assorted colors12 Ounce Bag
$2.99 -
Giant Jawbreakers 1 Jawbreaker, 2.5 Inches
Huge.2.5 inches
$1.99 -
Ginger Drops 12 ounce Bag
Ginger Drops 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Gobstopper Family Size 5 ounce Box
The jawbreaker that changes color in your mouth.
$1.99 -
Gold Nugget Gum 2 ounce Package
Gold Nugget Gum 2 ounce Package
$1.99 -
Hot Tamales 12 ounce Bag
Hot Tamales 12 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Ice Blue Peppermints 12 ounce Bag
Ice Blue Peppermints 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Jawbreakers 12 ounce
Assorted colors12 oz
$3.99 -
Jelly Nougats 8 ounce Bag
Chewy nougat candy with small chunks of jelly.8 oz
$3.99 -
Jolly Ranchers 12 ounce Bag
Bite SizeAssorted flavors:Apple, Blue Raspberry, Cherry, Grape, Watermelon12 Oz
$3.99 -
Jordan Almonds 5 Pound Box
Candy coated almonds-choose white or pastel.5 pound box
$31.99 -
Juicy Drop Pop .92 ounce
Squeeze the candy out of the pop!.92 OzChoose flavor:BLUE REBEL, KNOCK-OUT PUNCH, APPLE ATTACK, OR BERRY BOMB
$1.99 -
Laffy Taffy 8 ounce Bag
‘- Two jokes on each wrapper.Strawberry, grape, banana & sour apple. 8 oz
$2.99 -
Lemon Heads 12 ounce Bag
Lemon Heads 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Mallow Cups 1.6 ounce
Boyer’s famous chocolate cups filled with marshmallow creme.box of 24
$26.00 -
Mary Janes 12 ounce Bag
Old fashioned peanut butter taffy square.12 oz
$3.99 -
Marzipan 9 Piece
An almond paste delicacy.4 oz
$5.99 -
Mega Sour Warheads
20 ct
$2.99 -
Mike And Ikes 12 ounce Bag
Mike And Ikes 14 ounce 12 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Mint Julips 12 ounce Bag
Mint Juleps. The original mint taffy.14 oz
$3.99 -
Molasses Puffs 5 ounce Bag
Also called Sponge, Seafoam or Ferry Food.5 oz
$4.99 -
Necco Wafer 8 ounce Bag
Mini rolls of assorted flavorsNew All-natural formula16 rolls per bag8 oz
$3.99 -
Nerd Rope 10 Inches Long
Long gummi stick with Nerd candy beads stuck to it.10 inches long
$1.29 -
Peanut Brittle
12 Ounces
$5.99 -
Peanut Butter Cups
One Pound
$19.99 -
PEANUT BUTTER SMOOTHIE
‘- Boyer’s famous butterscotch filled peanut butter cup.box of 24
$24.00 -
Pecan Log 3 ounce Package
Pecans wrapped around a rich caramel & nougat filling.
$1.99 -
Pixie Stix 3.5 ounce Bag
Paper straws filled with pixie dust(flavored sugar).40 per bag
$2.99 -
Pop Rocks Strawberry 0.33 ounce Package
$0.99 -
Pop Rocks Tropical Punch 0.33 ounce Package
$0.99 -
Pop Rocks Watermelon 0.33 ounce Package
$0.99 -
Razzles Original 1.4 ounce Package
First it’s candy, then it’s gum.
$1.49 -
Razzles Sour 1.4 ounce Package
Sour flavorsFirst it’s candy, then it’s gum.
$1.49 -
Reed’s Rolls
Select Root Beer, Butterscotch or Cinnamon
$0.99 -
Reeses Pieces 8 ounce Bag
E.T.’s favorite peanut butter filled candy shells.10 oz
$3.99 -
Rock Candy 10 ounce Bag
Crystalized sugar on string.10 oz
$4.99 -
Rock Candy Stix
Assorted colors and flavors on swizzle stick.6 stix
$4.99 -
ROLO
Chewy Caramels in milk chocolate1.7 ounces
$1.29 -
Rootbeer Barrels 14 ounce Bag
Rootbeer Barrels 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Runts 12 ounce Bag
Fruit shaped hard candies from Willie Wonka.12 oz
$3.99 -
Scented Gum Box 8 Piece Box
20 Packs
$24.00 -
Sixlets 8 ounce Bag
Chocolate filledWhy DO they call them sixlets?8 oz
$3.99 -
Sky Bars Box Of 24
4 fillings in each bar.Vanilla, caramel, peanut butter & fudge.box of 36
$24.00 -
Smarties Wrapped 10 ounce Bag
Smarties Wrapped 10 ounce Bag
$2.99 -
Snocaps 10 ounce Bag
Tiny Dark Chocolate Nonpareils10 Oz
$3.99 -
Sour Power Straws 6 ounce Bag
Watermelon, strawberry & tropical punch chewy sour straws you can actually drink through.6 oz
$2.99 -
Squirrel Nut Zipper 12 ounce Bag
Vanilla version of the famous Squirrel.12 oz
$3.99 -
Sugar Daddies 8 ounce Bag
Caramel lollipops that last a long time.8 oz(about 15 pops)
$3.99 -
Tootsie Pop Drops 24-2.25 ounce Package
Tootsie Pops without the stick!24 2.25 Oz packages
$24.00 -
Tootsie Rolls 14 ounce Bag
Tootsie Rolls 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Tootsie Rolls Flavored 14 ounce Bag
Like the original Tootsie Roll, but in vanilla, cherry, orange, lemon & lime.14 oz
$3.99 -
Violet Squares 15 Mint Package
C.Howard’s The candy with the unmistakable violet flavor.15 mints per pack
$1.29 -
Wax Bottles
7 Ounces
$3.99 -
WAX FANGS
Each
$1.29 -
Wax Lips
each
$1.29 -
Wax Mustache
EACH
$1.29 -
WHISTLE POP
The lollipop that whistles actual songs
$0.99 -
Zagnut Bar
1.75 Ounces
$1.29 -
Zero Bar 1.85 ounce
EACH
$1.29
