Nostalgia
Showing all 102 results
-
Abba Zabba
First copyrighted in 1922, Abba Zabba is a chewy taffy with a peanut butter center. It was the favorite candy bar of actor John Wayne.
$1.99 -
Anise Squares
12 Ounces
$3.99 -
Atomic Fireballs 12 Ounce Bag
Great Balls of Fire!!!12 ounce bag
$3.99 -
BANANA CANDIES – 12 ounce bag
LIKE ASSORTED RUNTS, BUT JUST THE BEST FLAVOR
$3.99 -
Beemans Chewing Gum – 20 packs
Twenty packs of gum with five sticks in each pack.
$13.00 -
Bit-O-Honey 12 ounce Bag
Bite size molasses taffy with a tase of honey.12 oz
$3.99 -
Black Jack Chewing Gum – 20 packs
Twenty packs of licorice flavored gum with five sticks in each pack.
$13.00 -
Blo Pops 8 ounce Bag
Charms pops filled with bubble gum.Assorted flavors 10 oz
$3.99 -
Bonomo Banana Taffy 1.5 ounce Bar
Back by popular demand! Crack it up!1.5 Oz bar
$1.49 -
Bonomo Chocolate Taffy 1.5 ounce Bar
Back by popular demand!Crack it Up!1.5 Oz
$1.49 -
Bonomo Strawberry Taffy 1.5ounce Bar
Back by popular demand!Crack it Up!1.5 Oz bar
$1.49 -
Bonomo Vanilla Taffy 1.5 ounce Bar
Back by popular demand!Crack it Up!1.5 Oz bar
$1.49 -
Boston Baked Beans 12 ounce Bag
Fill your beanpot with the original Boston beans(candy coated peanuts)14 oz
$4.99 -
Bottle Caps Box 5 ounce
Cola, Cherry, Grape, Root Beer, Orange5 Oz
$1.99 -
Bubble Gum Cigarettes 8 Per Box
Blow smoke out with these.8 smokes per pack
$1.49 -
Bubble Gum Cigars
8 Count
$3.99 -
Butterfinger 2.5 ounce Bar
Butterfinger 2.5 ounce Bar
$1.29 -
Candy Blox
8 Ounces
$2.99 -
Candy Buttons
2 strips of candy pills to peel off the paper. Remember when you pretended to be the doctor.
$2.99 -
Caramel Apple Pops – 48 Count Box
$10.99 -
Charleston Chew Chocolate
Try Frozen 8 inches long
$1.29 -
Charleston Chew Strawberry
Try frozen 8 inches long
$1.29 -
Charleston Chew Vanilla
Try Frozen. 8 inches long
$1.29 -
Charms Lollipops – 48 Count Box
$14.99 -
Charms Lollipops – Sweet & Sour – 48 Count Box
$14.99 -
Chewy Spree 12 ounce Bag
Chewy Spree 12 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
CHICK-O-STICK
Each
$1.49 -
Chocolate Gummi Bears 8 ounces
Imported gummi bears covered with a special milk chocolate.
$5.99 -
Chocolate Necco Wafers – 2 ounce roll
$1.49 -
Chocolate Necco Wafers – 24 Rolls
24 – 2 ounce rolls
$29.99 -
Chocolate Starlite Mints 14 ounce Bag
Chocolate Starlite Mints 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Chuckles 2 ounce Package
Even the name says FUN!!!5 count
$1.29 -
Chunky Bar 1.4 ounce Bar
$1.49 -
Cinnamon Bears 10 ounce Container
Hot cinnamon flavored juji bears10 Oz
$3.99 -
Circus Peanuts – 8 ounce bag
$3.99 -
Clove Chewing Gum – 20 packs
Twenty packs of gum with five sticks in each pack.
$13.00 -
Coconut Haystacks 10 ounce Bag
Coconut Haystacks 10 ounce Bag
$5.99 -
CROWS
Theatre size box of black licorice buttons8.5 oz
$1.99 -
Cry Baby Teardrops 12 ounce Bag
Sour candies that will make you cry.12 oz
$3.99 -
DIVINITY 8 OZ CONTAINER
8 OZ OF DIVINITY WHIPPED NOUGAT WITH CHOPPED PECAN
$4.99 -
Dubble Bubble Gum 8 ounce Bag
Dubble Bubble Gum 8 ounce Bag
$2.99 -
DUM DUM POPS
8 ouncesaprox 30 pops
$3.99 -
Flying Saucers Box Of 240
Super-light wafers filled with candy beads.Did you “Play Church” with these? 240 saucers
$26.00 -
Frooties 8 ounce Bag
‘- Chewy Tootsie candies with intense flavors like Blue Raspberry, Grape, Green Apple, Lime Cola, Fruit Punch and more8 Oz assorted
$3.99 -
Fruit Barrels 14 ounce Bag
Fruit Barrels 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Fruit Stripe Gum – 17 Stick Package
5 Juicy Flavors with 17 sticks
$1.29 -
Giant Gumballs 12 Ounces
1 Inch Gumballs – assorted colors12 Ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Giant Jawbreakers 1 Jawbreaker, 2.5 Inches
Huge.2.5 inches
$1.99 -
Ginger Drops 12 ounce Bag
Ginger Drops 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Gobstopper Family Size 5 ounce Box
The jawbreaker that changes color in your mouth.
$1.99 -
Hot Tamales – 12 ounce Bag
Hot Tamales 12 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Jawbreakers 12 ounce
Assorted colors12 oz
$3.99 -
Jelly Nougats 8 ounce Bag
Chewy nougat candy with small chunks of jelly.8 oz
$3.99 -
Jolly Ranchers 12 ounce Bag
Bite SizeAssorted flavors:Apple, Blue Raspberry, Cherry, Grape, Watermelon12 Oz
$3.99 -
Laffy Taffy 8 ounce Bag
‘- Two jokes on each wrapper.Strawberry, grape, banana & sour apple. 8 oz
$3.99 -
Lemon Heads 12 ounce Bag
Lemon Heads 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Mallow Cups 1.6 ounce
Boyer’s famous chocolate cups filled with marshmallow creme.box of 24
$28.00 -
Marzipan 9 Piece
An almond paste delicacy.4 oz
$6.99 -
Mega Sour Warheads
20 ct
$2.99 -
Mike And Ikes 12 ounce Bag
Mike And Ikes 12 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Milk Maid Royals – 8 ounce bag
Old fashioned English toffees. Six flavors; Butter Rum, Maple, Vanilla, Chocolate, Orange, Raspberry
$3.99 -
Molasses Puffs 5 ounce Bag
Also called Sponge, Seafoam or Ferry Food.5 oz
$4.99 -
Necco Wafers – 2 ounce roll
Roll of assorted flavors – 2 ounces
$1.49 -
Necco Wafers – 24 Rolls
Box of 24 Rolls of assorted flavors – 2 ounces each
$29.99 -
NERD FILLED GUM – 8 ounce bag
$3.99 -
Nerd Rope 10 Inches Long
Long gummi stick with Nerd candy beads stuck to it.10 inches long
$1.49 -
Now and Later – 8 ounce bag
$3.99 -
Peanut Brittle
12 Ounces
$5.99 -
Peanut Butter Cups
One Pound
$24.99 -
PEANUT BUTTER SMOOTHIE
‘- Boyer’s famous butterscotch filled peanut butter cup.box of 24
$28.00 -
Pecan Log 3 ounce Package
Pecans wrapped around a rich caramel & nougat filling.
$1.99 -
Pixie Stix 3.5 ounce Bag
Paper straws filled with pixie dust(flavored sugar).40 per bag
$2.99 -
Pop Rocks Strawberry 0.33 ounce Package
$0.99 -
Pop Rocks Tropical Punch 0.33 ounce Package
$0.99 -
Pop Rocks Watermelon 0.33 ounce Package
$0.99 -
Razzles Original 1.4 ounce Package
First it’s candy, then it’s gum.
$1.49 -
Razzles Sour 1.4 ounce Package
Sour flavorsFirst it’s candy, then it’s gum.
$1.49 -
Reed’s Rolls
Select Root Beer, Butterscotch or Cinnamon
$0.99 -
Reeses Pieces 8 ounce Bag
E.T.’s favorite peanut butter filled candy shells.10 oz
$3.99 -
Rock Candy 10 ounce Bag
Crystalized sugar on string.10 oz
$4.99 -
Rock Candy Stix
Assorted colors and flavors on swizzle stick.6 stix
$4.99 -
ROLO
Chewy Caramels in milk chocolate1.7 ounces
$1.29 -
Rootbeer Barrels 14 ounce Bag
Rootbeer Barrels 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Scented Gum Box 8 Piece Box
20 Packs
$24.00 -
Sixlets 8 ounce Bag
Chocolate filledWhy DO they call them sixlets?8 oz
$3.99 -
Sky Bars Box Of 24
4 fillings in each bar.Vanilla, caramel, peanut butter & fudge.box of 24
$59.99 -
Smarties Wrapped 10 ounce Bag
Smarties Wrapped 10 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Snocaps 10 ounce Bag
Tiny Dark Chocolate Nonpareils10 Oz
$5.99 -
Sour Power Straws 6 ounce Bag
Watermelon, strawberry & tropical punch chewy sour straws you can actually drink through.6 oz
$3.99 -
Sugar Babies 1.7 ounce pouch
Chewy, soft to chew, milk caramel sweets
$1.29 -
Sugar Daddies 8 ounce Bag
Caramel lollipops that last a long time.8 oz(about 15 pops)
$3.99 -
Tart N Tiny – 1.5 ounce
$1.99 -
Tootsie Pop Drops 2.25 ounce Package
Tootsie Pops without the stick! 2.25 Oz package
$1.49 -
Tootsie Rolls 14 ounce Bag
Tootsie Rolls 14 ounce Bag
$3.99 -
Tootsie Rolls Flavored 14 ounce Bag
Like the original Tootsie Roll, but in vanilla, cherry, orange, lemon & lime.14 oz
$3.99 -
Violet Squares 15 Mint Package
C.Howard’s The candy with the unmistakable violet flavor.15 mints per pack
$1.29 -
Wacky Wafers – 5 piece
Green Apple, Strawberry, Orange, Watermelon, Banana
$1.99 -
Wax Bottles
7 Ounces
$4.99 -
WAX FANGS
Each
$1.49 -
Wax Lips
each
$1.49 -
Wax Mustache
EACH
$1.49 -
Zero Bar 1.85 ounce
EACH
$1.29
